With this cabin, you're getting two big things: an incredible view of the lake -- it's practically IN the living room and the screen porch -- and historic atmosphere. You're also getting wonderful hospitality from the host and some great amenities, like both charcoal and gas grills to choose from and a wide selection of boats and even fishing poles to deploy for free (there are lures aplenty, too, but worms and other bait are on you ;-)
This is a ~100-year-old fishing cabin. It's furnished very nicely and simply, and it has good WiFi and a decent TV setup, but it's still fairly rustic. There's a certain level of dust you just can't get out of an old cabin like this in the middle of the woods. That being said, the cleaning could be a little more diligent, especially of the windows and sills, and the kitchen could use some modest upgrades, like new linoleum. Other reviewers were appalled by this, but I don't think it's that bad. I'd feel differently for a pricier place -- which many lakeside cabins situated so beautifully are -- but to my mind this is a great value for what it is.
One other key caveat: Lake Champlain is spectacular and soul-nourishing, but it can be a bit of a mixed bag, too. Global warming has led to lots of algae, weeds and zebra mussels where you want to swim, so that's something to keep in mind and ask about.
Overall, we loved this place and the surrounding countryside and could've spent weeks on end here. Would happily come back (and wish it were closer to our home in NYC)!!